Betting tips from AI for Edmonton Oilers vs New York Islanders, 16 January 2026.

Edmonton arrives as the slight favorite 1.87 on home ice while the Islanders sit a juicy underdog at 3.50 (draw listed 4.30). This rematch has narrative edges: Bo Horvat’s red-hot 27 points and New York’s tidy 8-4-1 road form give the Isles real momentum, and they already beat Edmonton in October.

Edmonton still leans on Connor McDavid (36 points) and a motivated Zach Hyman after his two-goal night, but the Oilers’ 11-11-5 record and a troubling trend of under 1.5 first-period goals in 8 of the last 9 meetings with New York make them vulnerable early.

Given the combination of value and situational matchup — Islanders’ depth scoring, road confidence, and Edmonton’s slow starts — the smart, profitable play is to back the New York Islanders at 3.50.

The Edmonton Oilers, despite Connor McDavid's league-leading 36 points, find themselves in a challenging spot with a middling 11-11-5 record. While Zach Hyman's two-goal effort against Nashville showed flashes, their recent 4-3 overtime loss suggests lingering inconsistencies. At home, they are priced at 1.87, a short line for a team still desperate for a sustained boost.

Conversely, the New York Islanders are rolling, fueled by captain Bo Horvat's 27 points, boasting an impressive 14-10-3 record and a formidable 8-4-1 away form. They already triumphed over the Oilers in October, demonstrating their capability against this very opponent. History also suggests caution for Edmonton, as they've struggled to score early against the Islanders, netting under 1.5 goals in the first period in 8 of their last 9 clashes.

The Islanders at 3.50 present significant value. Their current form, strong road performance, and previous victory over the Oilers, combined with Edmonton's struggles and historical difficulties in this matchup, make them the smart play. The value heavily favors the visitors.

The Oilers-Islanders matchup presents an intriguing betting opportunity with Edmonton favored at 1.87 despite their inconsistent 11-11-5 start. While the Islanders bring momentum with their 14-10-3 record and Horvat's impressive 27-point performance, Edmonton has the x-factor in Connor McDavid (36 points) and Zach Hyman's recent two-goal showing against Nashville.

The Islanders' road record (8-4-1) can't be overlooked, nor can their October victory over Edmonton. However, Rogers Place creates a significant home-ice advantage where the Oilers typically elevate their game. The 3.50 odds on New York are tempting but ultimately misleading.

With Edmonton desperate to improve their standing and McDavid consistently producing at an elite level, expect the Oilers to overcome their early-period scoring woes against New York (under 1.5 goals in 8 of their last 9 meetings) and secure a narrow victory in what should be a tightly contested affair.

The Edmonton Oilers host the New York Islanders in a pivotal NHL clash at Rogers Place, where desperation meets momentum. Edmonton's 11-11-5 start has them clinging to 27 points, but with Connor McDavid's league-leading 36 points and Zach Hyman's recent two-goal heroics in a tough OT loss to Nashville, the Oilers are primed for redemption. Facing a New York side that's won their October matchup, Edmonton boasts home-ice advantage against the Isles' solid 8-4-1 away record.

Bo Horvat's scorching 27 points have propelled the Islanders to 14-10-3 and 31 points, but history tempers optimism: Edmonton has struggled to score early, under 1.5 goals in the first period in 8 of their last 9 against New York. Still, the Oilers' offensive firepower, led by McDavid, should overwhelm a raucous crowd's energy.

At 1.87 for Edmonton, this screams value over the Isles' 3.50 underdog price and the unlikely 4.30 draw. Betting $1 on the Oilers nets a smart, profitable edge in this high-stakes rematch.

The New York Islanders ride high with captain Bo Horvat's 27-point surge, powering a 14-10-3 record and offering sharp value at 3.50. Their 8-4-1 road form and October win over Edmonton set the stage.

Connor McDavid's 36 points anchor the Oilers, but their 11-11-5 start and history of slow starts—under 1.5 first-period goals in 8 of 9 clashes with New York—spell trouble.

Despite Zach Hyman's recent two-goal effort in a loss, the Isles' discipline and momentum make them a profitable pick to edge a desperate Oilers squad at Rogers Place.

The Edmonton Oilers and New York Islanders are set to clash in what promises to be a tightly contested NHL matchup. The Islanders, led by their red-hot captain Bo Horvat (27 points this season), come into Rogers Place with a solid 14-10-3 record. Their away form has been particularly impressive at 8-4-1, suggesting they won’t be easily intimidated by the Oilers' home crowd. Meanwhile, Connor McDavid’s brilliance continues to shine through for Edmonton, as he tops the team scoring charts with 36 points. However, the Oilers’ middling 11-11-5 start raises concerns about their consistency.

Historical trends also paint a cautious picture for Edmonton. They’ve struggled to score early, netting under 1.5 goals in the first period during 8 of their last 9 meetings with the Islanders. This could play into New York’s hands, given their disciplined defensive structure on the road. Furthermore, the Islanders already claimed victory over the Oilers earlier this season, adding psychological pressure on the hosts.

Bookmaker odds reflect these dynamics: Edmonton is favored at 1.87, while the Islanders sit at 3.50 and the draw is listed at 4.30. Given Edmonton's inconsistent performances and New York’s strong away record, backing the Islanders presents significant value. A bet on the Islanders offers both higher potential returns and aligns with their current momentum and historical edge against Edmonton.