English
English (US)
Betting tips from AI for Manchester United vs Manchester City, 17 January 2026.
AI Consensus
2.23
Away win
5 of 6 AI models pick Manchester City to win at
2.23
ChatGPT tip
Manchester United win
3.27
ChatGPT prediction for Manchester United vs Manchester City, 17 January 2026.
I expect value on Manchester United given the price and derby dynamics. Bookmakers make City slight favorites at 1.94, while United are priced long at 3.68 and a draw sits at 4.01. The market is rightly wary of City's form, but those odds understate derby variance and the uplift an interim manager can produce.
City's 13-game unbeaten run is impressive, yet injuries and rotation after heavy cup results introduce cracks. Carrick's first match often brings a tactical reset and intensity at Old Trafford, and Manchester United still create chances against top sides. Backing United at this price offers upside — a profitable one-dollar stab at an outcome the books may be underpricing.
City's 13-game unbeaten run is impressive, yet injuries and rotation after heavy cup results introduce cracks. Carrick's first match often brings a tactical reset and intensity at Old Trafford, and Manchester United still create chances against top sides. Backing United at this price offers upside — a profitable one-dollar stab at an outcome the books may be underpricing.
Gemini tip
Manchester City win
2.23
Gemini prediction for Manchester United vs Manchester City, 17 January 2026.
Manchester City rolls into Old Trafford on a phenomenal 13-game unbeaten streak across all competitions, showcasing dominant form that has them trailing Arsenal by just six points. Their recent thrashing of Exeter 10-1 and a comfortable 2-0 win against Newcastle underscore their attacking prowess. In stark contrast, Manchester United is in disarray, with new interim boss Michael Carrick taking the helm after just one win in their last six Premier League matches and a recent FA Cup defeat to Brighton.
While the derby atmosphere is always unpredictable, City's superior quality and momentum are undeniable. Bookmakers assign City a 51% win probability, reflected in their 1.94 odds. Despite some injury concerns, the potential Premier League debut of £64 million signing Semenyo, who has impressed in cup competitions, adds another weapon to City's arsenal. Expect City to leverage United's disorganized midfield and secure a crucial away victory.
While the derby atmosphere is always unpredictable, City's superior quality and momentum are undeniable. Bookmakers assign City a 51% win probability, reflected in their 1.94 odds. Despite some injury concerns, the potential Premier League debut of £64 million signing Semenyo, who has impressed in cup competitions, adds another weapon to City's arsenal. Expect City to leverage United's disorganized midfield and secure a crucial away victory.
Claude tip
Manchester City win
2.23
Claude prediction for Manchester United vs Manchester City, 17 January 2026.
The Manchester derby arrives with City in commanding form, riding a 13-game unbeaten streak across all competitions, while United enter a new era under interim manager Michael Carrick. City's odds of 1.94 reflect their status as favorites, compared to United's lengthy 3.68.
Carrick faces an immediate baptism of fire, with United winning just one of their last six Premier League matches. Their disorganized midfield will likely struggle against City's technical superiority, though they do create chances that could trouble City's occasionally vulnerable defense.
The £64 million January signing Semenyo is poised for his Premier League debut after impressing in cup competitions, adding another dimension to City's already potent attack. Despite City's injury concerns, their quality and form suggest they should overcome United, even in the emotionally charged atmosphere of Old Trafford.
The value bet lies with Manchester City, whose superior quality and momentum should prevail against a United team in transition.
Carrick faces an immediate baptism of fire, with United winning just one of their last six Premier League matches. Their disorganized midfield will likely struggle against City's technical superiority, though they do create chances that could trouble City's occasionally vulnerable defense.
The £64 million January signing Semenyo is poised for his Premier League debut after impressing in cup competitions, adding another dimension to City's already potent attack. Despite City's injury concerns, their quality and form suggest they should overcome United, even in the emotionally charged atmosphere of Old Trafford.
The value bet lies with Manchester City, whose superior quality and momentum should prevail against a United team in transition.
Grok tip
Manchester City win
2.23
Grok prediction for Manchester United vs Manchester City, 17 January 2026.
The Manchester derby always delivers fireworks, and this clash at Old Trafford on January 17, 2026, promises to be no different. Manchester City arrive as red-hot favorites, riding a 13-game unbeaten streak across all competitions and unbeaten in their last nine Premier League outings. Their attacking prowess was on full display with a 10-1 FA Cup thrashing of Exeter, bolstered by new signing Semenyo's impressive debut—two goals and man-of-the-match honors in cups. Despite trailing Arsenal by six points, City's quality shines through.
Contrast that with Manchester United's turmoil. Interim boss Michael Carrick faces a baptism of fire after a dismal run: just one win in their last six league games and three straight draws. A 2-1 FA Cup loss to Brighton underscores their struggles, though they still generate chances. City's injury list might thin their attack, but their midfield dominance should overwhelm United's disorganized setup.
Bookies reflect this with City at 1.94 (51% implied win probability), United at 3.68 (28.6%), and draw at 4.01. Experts split on scorelines—some eye a 2-2 thriller, others City's 3-1 romp—but both teams to score and over 2.5 goals feels likely given defensive frailties. For value, City's edge makes them the smart play in this high-stakes showdown.
Contrast that with Manchester United's turmoil. Interim boss Michael Carrick faces a baptism of fire after a dismal run: just one win in their last six league games and three straight draws. A 2-1 FA Cup loss to Brighton underscores their struggles, though they still generate chances. City's injury list might thin their attack, but their midfield dominance should overwhelm United's disorganized setup.
Bookies reflect this with City at 1.94 (51% implied win probability), United at 3.68 (28.6%), and draw at 4.01. Experts split on scorelines—some eye a 2-2 thriller, others City's 3-1 romp—but both teams to score and over 2.5 goals feels likely given defensive frailties. For value, City's edge makes them the smart play in this high-stakes showdown.
DeepSeek tip
Manchester City win
2.23
DeepSeek prediction for Manchester United vs Manchester City, 17 January 2026.
In this Manchester derby, Manchester City's dominant form positions them as the clear favorite. They enter on a 13-game unbeaten streak, with a recent 10-1 FA Cup thrashing of Exeter highlighting their attacking firepower.
United is in turmoil under interim boss Michael Carrick, having won just one of their last six Premier League matches. City's new £64M signing Semenyo is set for his league debut, bolstering their attack despite some injury concerns.
With odds at 1.94 for City, bookmakers mirror expert predictions of a 51% win probability. United at 3.68 offers long-shot value, but City's quality should prevail in a high-scoring encounter.
United is in turmoil under interim boss Michael Carrick, having won just one of their last six Premier League matches. City's new £64M signing Semenyo is set for his league debut, bolstering their attack despite some injury concerns.
With odds at 1.94 for City, bookmakers mirror expert predictions of a 51% win probability. United at 3.68 offers long-shot value, but City's quality should prevail in a high-scoring encounter.
Qwen tip
Manchester City win
2.23
Qwen prediction for Manchester United vs Manchester City, 17 January 2026.
This Manchester derby presents a fascinating clash of circumstances, with the bookmakers favoring Manchester City at odds of 1.94, while Manchester United sit at 3.68, and a draw is priced at 4.01. Despite Michael Carrick’s interim appointment injecting some hope into Old Trafford, United's poor form—just one win in their last six Premier League games—makes them underdogs. Meanwhile, City arrives on a 13-game unbeaten streak, showcasing both attacking flair and defensive resilience.
City’s recent demolition of Exeter 10-1 in the FA Cup highlights their offensive firepower, even as they integrate new signing Semenyo, who has already impressed with two goals in cup competitions. However, injuries to key players could slightly blunt their edge. On the flip side, United’s struggles are evident, but their knack for creating chances keeps them dangerous in transition. The derby atmosphere might also galvanize the home side, though it’s unlikely to bridge the quality gap entirely.
The odds suggest value in backing City, whose superior form and tactical cohesion outweigh United’s potential emotional lift. While a high-scoring encounter seems probable given both teams’ tendencies, City’s consistency makes them the safer bet to secure all three points.
City’s recent demolition of Exeter 10-1 in the FA Cup highlights their offensive firepower, even as they integrate new signing Semenyo, who has already impressed with two goals in cup competitions. However, injuries to key players could slightly blunt their edge. On the flip side, United’s struggles are evident, but their knack for creating chances keeps them dangerous in transition. The derby atmosphere might also galvanize the home side, though it’s unlikely to bridge the quality gap entirely.
The odds suggest value in backing City, whose superior form and tactical cohesion outweigh United’s potential emotional lift. While a high-scoring encounter seems probable given both teams’ tendencies, City’s consistency makes them the safer bet to secure all three points.
Match News
# Manchester United vs Manchester City - Match Preview
## Expert Predictions
• Michael Carrick's managerial debut under pressure: One analyst predicts City will dominate with a 3-1 victory, arguing the visitors have too much quality for United's disorganized midfield, though he acknowledges the derby atmosphere could produce surprises at Old Trafford[5].
• Divided forecasts on the scoreline: Predictions range widely—some experts back a 2-2 draw citing both teams' recent form, while others favor City's superior quality, with bookmakers assigning Manchester City a 51% win probability compared to United's 28.6%[2][3][4].
• Both teams expected to score: Analysts highlight that United create numerous chances despite poor recent form, while City's defensive vulnerabilities suggest a high-scoring encounter with over 2.5 goals likely[2].
## Recent Form & Context
• United's managerial transition: New interim boss Michael Carrick takes charge for the first time after the club's recent struggles, with the Red Devils having won just one of their last six Premier League matches and drawing three consecutive league games[5].
• City's dominant run: Manchester City enters on a 13-game unbeaten streak across all competitions and remain undefeated in their last nine Premier League matches, though they trail Arsenal by six points[1].
• Contrasting recent results: City thrashed Exeter 10-1 in the FA Cup and secured a 2-0 first-leg win against Newcastle in the EFL Cup semi-finals, while United suffered a 2-1 FA Cup third-round defeat to Brighton[1][5].
## Squad News
• Semenyo's Premier League debut looms: City's £64 million January signing from Bournemouth is set for his league debut after impressing in cup competitions with two goals and multiple man-of-the-match displays[1][3].
• City's injury concerns: Manchester City faces a growing list of absences that could impact their attacking options for the derby[3].
## Expert Predictions
• Michael Carrick's managerial debut under pressure: One analyst predicts City will dominate with a 3-1 victory, arguing the visitors have too much quality for United's disorganized midfield, though he acknowledges the derby atmosphere could produce surprises at Old Trafford[5].
• Divided forecasts on the scoreline: Predictions range widely—some experts back a 2-2 draw citing both teams' recent form, while others favor City's superior quality, with bookmakers assigning Manchester City a 51% win probability compared to United's 28.6%[2][3][4].
• Both teams expected to score: Analysts highlight that United create numerous chances despite poor recent form, while City's defensive vulnerabilities suggest a high-scoring encounter with over 2.5 goals likely[2].
## Recent Form & Context
• United's managerial transition: New interim boss Michael Carrick takes charge for the first time after the club's recent struggles, with the Red Devils having won just one of their last six Premier League matches and drawing three consecutive league games[5].
• City's dominant run: Manchester City enters on a 13-game unbeaten streak across all competitions and remain undefeated in their last nine Premier League matches, though they trail Arsenal by six points[1].
• Contrasting recent results: City thrashed Exeter 10-1 in the FA Cup and secured a 2-0 first-leg win against Newcastle in the EFL Cup semi-finals, while United suffered a 2-1 FA Cup third-round defeat to Brighton[1][5].
## Squad News
• Semenyo's Premier League debut looms: City's £64 million January signing from Bournemouth is set for his league debut after impressing in cup competitions with two goals and multiple man-of-the-match displays[1][3].
• City's injury concerns: Manchester City faces a growing list of absences that could impact their attacking options for the derby[3].
See how multiple AI models rate Manchester United vs Manchester City. We aggregate today's
betting tips and highlight agreement between models when it occurs. Use this page to scan the overall
picture quickly, then open any model's detailed tip to read short reasoning.