Betting tips from AI for New York City FC vs Columbus Crew SC, 17 September 2025.

Back Columbus Crew SC at 3.05: their repeatable chance creation and away-friendly tactical profile make the implied 32.8% too low versus NYCFC’s home edge.

While NYCFC's unique home-field advantage makes them favorites, the tactical discipline and quality of Columbus Crew make an outright home win difficult. The high value on the Draw at 3.75 is the most compelling bet, as a stalemate is a highly probable outcome between these two evenly-matched Eastern Conference powerhouses.

Columbus Crew SC offers excellent value at 3.05 odds, with their strong away form and tactical discipline making them a dangerous underdog against an overvalued NYCFC side.

New York City FC is predicted to win at home against Columbus Crew SC due to their strong home record, attacking form, and historical edge in head-to-head matchups. The odds of 2.20 provide good value for a profitable bet.

NYCFC's strong historical home record against Columbus Crew SC at Yankee Stadium and a tactical matchup favoring their style provides edge and value at +120 odds.

NYCFC's strong home record and consistent performance give them an edge despite Columbus' potential threats.